Criticism and Fiction

Author: William Dean Howells


In the mean time the average of criticism is not wholly bad with us. To be sure, the critic sometimes appears in the panoply of the savages whom we have supplanted on this continent; and it is hard to believe that his use of the tomahawk and the scalping-knife is a form of conservative surgery. It is still his conception of his office that he should assail those who differ with him in matters of taste or opinion; that he must be rude with those he does not like. It is too largely his superstition that because he likes a thing it is good, and because he dislikes a thing it is bad; the reverse is quite possibly the case, but he is yet indefinitely far from knowing that in affairs of taste his personal preference enters very little. Commonly he has no principles, but only an assortment of prepossessions for and against; and this otherwise very perfect character is sometimes uncandid to the verge of dishonesty. He seems not to mind misstating the position of any one he supposes himself to disagree with, and then attacking him for what he never said, or even implied; he thinks this is droll, and appears not to suspect that it is immoral. He is not tolerant; he thinks it a virtue to be intolerant; it is hard for him to understand that the same thing may be admirable at one time and deplorable at another; and that it is really his business to classify and analyze the fruits of the human mind very much as the naturalist classifies the objects of his study, rather than to praise or blame them; that there is a measure of the same absurdity in his trampling on a poem, a novel, or an essay that does not please him as in the botanist’s grinding a plant underfoot because he does not find it pretty. He does not conceive that it is his business rather to identify the species and then explain how and where the specimen is imperfect and irregular. If he could once acquire this simple idea of his duty he would be much more agreeable company than he now is, and a more useful member of society; though considering the hard conditions under which he works, his necessity of writing hurriedly from an imperfect examination of far more books, on a greater variety of subjects, than he can even hope to read, the average American critic—the ordinary critic of commerce, so to speak—is even now very, well indeed. Collectively he is more than this; for the joint effect of our criticism is the pretty thorough appreciation of any book submitted to it


Related Resources

American Non-fiction

Download Options

Title: Criticism and Fiction

Select an option:

*Note: A download may not start for up to 60 seconds.

Email Options

Title: Criticism and Fiction

Select an option:

Email addres:

*Note: It may take up to 60 seconds for for the email to be generated.

Chicago: William Dean Howells, "VI.," Criticism and Fiction, ed. Davis, Charles Belmont, 1866-1926 in Criticism and Fiction (New York: Doubleday, Page & Company, 1909), Original Sources, accessed March 18, 2019,

MLA: Howells, William Dean. "VI." Criticism and Fiction, edited by Davis, Charles Belmont, 1866-1926, in Criticism and Fiction, Vol. 22, New York, Doubleday, Page & Company, 1909, Original Sources. 18 Mar. 2019.

Harvard: Howells, WD, 'VI.' in Criticism and Fiction, ed. . cited in 1909, Criticism and Fiction, Doubleday, Page & Company, New York. Original Sources, retrieved 18 March 2019, from